Real-time applications of Music Information Retrieval (MIR) have been gaining interest as of recently. However, as deep learning becomes more and more ubiquitous for music analysis tasks, several challenges and limitations need to be overcome to deliver accurate and quick real-time MIR systems. In addition, modern embedded computers offer great potential for compact systems that use MIR algorithms, such as digital musical instruments. However, embedded computing hardware is generally resource constrained, posing additional limitations. In this paper, we identify and discuss the challenges and limitations of embedded real-time MIR. Furthermore, we discuss potential solutions to these challenges, and demonstrate their validity by presenting an embedded real-time classifier of expressive acoustic guitar techniques. The classifier achieved 99.2% accuracy in distinguishing pitched and percussive techniques and a 99.1% average accuracy in distinguishing four distinct percussive techniques with a fifth class for pitched sounds. The full classification task is a considerably more complex learning problem, with our preliminary results reaching only 56.5% accuracy. The results were produced with an average latency of 30.7 ms.

Download

Recent advancements in deep learning have shown great potential for audio applications, improving the accuracy of previous solutions for tasks such as music transcription, beat detection, and real-time audio processing. In addition, the availability of increasingly powerful embedded computers has led many deep learning framework developers to devise software optimized to run pretrained models in resource-constrained contexts. As a result, the use of deep learning on embedded devices and audio plugins has become more widespread. However, confusion has been rising around deep learning inference engines, regarding which of these can run in real-time and which are less resource-hungry. In this paper, we present a comparison of four available deep learning inference engines for real-time audio classification on the CPU of an embedded single-board computer: TensorFlow Lite, TorchScript, ONNX Runtime, and RTNeural. Results show that all inference engines can execute neural network models in real-time with appropriate code practices, but execution time varies between engines and models. Most importantly, we found that most of the less-specialized engines offer great flexibility and can be used effectively for real-time audio classification, with slightly better results than a real-time-specific approach. In contrast, more specialized solutions can offer a lightweight and minimalist alternative where less flexibility is needed.

Download